Lower Grammar Narrations – This is something I add to what’s listed for LG Tapestry students. I’ve previously shared about the workbox system I use to aid in independent Tapestry work at this level. In addition to that time, I spend 20 to 30 minutes with my LG students twice a week. Most of this Mom-time is spent with read alouds and narrations. My LG students have an encyclopedia that is not included in Tapestry’s reading assignments and I read a two page spread from that and have them narrate back what they learned. Usually, the encyclopedia covers one of the main Tapestry themes from the week. We were in Ancient Mesopotamia last week and she did a narration on the birth of writing. Other books that I read aloud to them might be an option for narration as well. Some books are read for fun or exposure at this age. I have no desire to take away from thatl. Others might be read independenty. Typically, the narration might be of a particular event (Tower of Babel, for instance) or of a major figure like Moses or Abram.
I recently shared a few samples of my current 2nd grader’s narrations with a friend. I was amazed at the difference in her ability when I compared the narrations she gave in week one to those given in week 3. This is a middle of the road sample of Abby’s current narrations.
Sumerian Daily Life
Sumerian Farmers worked hard. They raised crops and tended canals. Sumerians used a lot of pottery. They invented the wheel. Most lived in small, one story houses made of mud brick.
Upper Grammar Narrations - My Upper Grammar students follow a template for their Tapestry work each week. We transition from oral narrations to written summaries betwen 2nd and 3rd grade. When their template asks for a biographical summary they write about one of the main figures from that week. Last week it would have been Moses, but it might be Michaelangelo or President Roosevelt depending on the week. They also write event summaries. This would be a narrative on a war or other major event. Literature summaries are done when I want them to summarize a book they’ve read. I usually put a post it note on the book when I hand it to them to note that assigment. As a clarification, we do use Writing Aids and it’s been a great program for us, but the assignments often move at a snail’s pace from week to week. I want them in the habit of daily written response to their learning. These summaries are corrected during their weekly Tapestry meeting time with me and are revised as needed.
A recent summary from Holly’s folder:
Moses
Moses was born in Egypt when Pharaoh sent out the order that all Hebrew newborn boys would be thrown into the Nile. His Mom made a basket for him and put him in it. Then she put him in the river. She sent her daughter, Miriam, to watch over him. The Pharaoh’s daughter was swimming in the Nile and found the basket. She raised Moses as an Egyptian prince. When he was older he killed an Egyptian and fled from Egypt. Then God called him to lead the Israelites out of Egypt.
I find that summaries at this age vary greatly by topic and mood of the student. Sometimes they flourish and other times they’re somewhat stiff. This one is a bit stiff, but that’s okay. She clearly understands the flow of events and can write about them from memory in a cohesive enough manner.
Dialectic Level Outlines – We’ve used many recommendations from The Well Trained Mind through the years and I’m quite sure this sequence comes from SWB, but sometimes it is a help to see it fleshed out in someone else’s home and with a different curricula. I also have a Montessori background and have a strong inclination to have my children research and respond. My LG, UG, and D students have grade level encyclopedias that they use for this research. I mentioned that my LG narrates from hers after read aloud time with me. My UG student uses hers for summaries and my Dialectic students use them for outlining. We use Rod and Staff for English, so teaching them how to do this has never been a problem. I believe The Well Trained Mind breaks it down further, but we’ve rarely needed to do that. We do start with main points from articles first and then we move into supporting points and multi-paragraph articles/outlines.
My kids need to write – a lot. They’d breeze through Tapestry’s one writing assignment per week way too quickly if we didn’t add this to their week. I think (or hope) that it’s given them meaningful work to do around meaningful material and that it’s providing vocabulary enrichment, mental training in remembering or finding key points, and ease with writing. We’ll see if they learn to write well by the end of high school…
